Prabhupada: (devotees chant
responsively:) Om namo bhagavate vasudevaya.
rajovaca
pravrtti-margah kathita
adau bhagavata
yatha
krama-yogopalabdhena
brahmana yad asamsrtih
[SB
6.1.1]
So we have discussed the last two days what is the aim of
life. So this whole Krsna consciousness movement is diverting the aim of life.
There are two ways. Our present position, the aim of life is sense
gratification. Yan maithunadi-grhamedhi-sukham hi tuccham [SB 7.9.45]. Material
life means sense gratification, as much as possible. And the central point of
sense gratification is sex life. Yan maithunadi. Maithuna means sexual
intercourse. This is the machine to keep the living entity bound up under the
condition of material nature. We are conditioned by the material nature. We are
thinking we are free. We are not free. That is not the fact. Therefore Krsna
says in the Bhagavad-gita that "You are thinking that you are free, whatever you
like, can do, enjoy sense gratification -- but under condition. You are not
free."
So there are different grades of
sense gratification, but the point is sense gratification. The cats and dogs,
the animals, they are also satisfying their senses, and the human being also
engaged in the same business. The cats and dogs, they are eating to their taste;
the human being is also eating to their taste. The standard may be different,
but the taste is the same. Either you have sex intercourse with beautiful wife
or husband or as sex intercourse between the she-dog and he-dog, the enjoyment
is the same. Just like if you have got a palatable food, either you put it into
a golden pot or if you put it into iron pot, the taste is the same. The taste is
not different. One may think that "I am eating in golden pot; therefore I am
advanced." But a learned man will say that "Whether you have changed the taste?"
Either you drink something palatable in a golden pot or in iron pot or paper
pot, the taste is the same. So this is called pravrtti-marga. Pravrtti-marga
means advancing in sense gratification.
So there are different grades.
From the animal life we come to human life, and if we like, we can go to the
higher planetary system, Janaloka, Maharloka, Tapaloka. There are many planetary
system above the sun. We have already discussed, above the sun... The moon
planet is above the sun. The moon planet is not so near. So Krsna says that even
if you go to the highest planetary system, Brahmaloka... That is many thousands
years you can live and gratify your senses to higher standard than in this...
Suppose you are drinking here in golden pot; there you will get in diamond pot.
That will be the change, not that the taste will change. The taste, the same.
The dog's pot and man's pot and demigod's pot, within the material world, the
taste is the same, and ultimately, you have to die. That's all. That you cannot
stop. Nobody wants to die. He wants to enjoy life perpetually. Now the
scientists are trying to live more years. So what is the use of living more
years? The sastra says, taravah kim na jivanti [SB 2.3.18] . The trees they live
for five thousand years or more than that. So do they not live long years? So
sane man will think that "What is the use of living for five hundred or five
thousand years, standing in one place?"
So this is not advancement. The
advancement is that, as Krsna says, that to solve the problem of birth, death,
old age, and disease. That is advancement. So Krsna says, therefore, that
abrahma-bhuvanal lokan punar avartino 'rjuna. Even if you go... Why to the moon
planet? Even if you go to the topmost planet, which is called Brahmaloka...
There you can live for many millions of years, but you have to die. As you have
to die here, as the cats dies, dog dies... We human being, we also die. The
demigods, they also die. The Brahma will also die. Nobody can save himself from
death. Death... Birth, death, old age, and disease. We have already discussed
that we living beings, soul, we are eternal. We are eternal, we are simply
changing the body, one body to another. In this way, material life means you can
live for one minute or one hour or hundred years or millions of years. You get a
particular type of body, and according to that body, you live. And therefore you
have to die. Krsna says that abrahma-bhuvanal lokan punar avartino 'rjuna. Even
if you go to the topmost planet, you can live for long, long years, but you will
have to die and again come to this earthly planet and again begin your life.
This is going on. So how it is going on? Pravrtti-marga. "I want to enjoy sense
gratification." This is the basic principle. So this Krsna consciousness
movement means that back to home, back to Godhead, not to make proceed or
progress towards birth, death, old age, and disease, but make progress towards
no birth, no death, no old age, no disease. That is Krsna consciousness. That is
called nivrtti-marga. Nivrtti-marga. Nivrtti means stop this type of
progress.
So there are indication in the
sastra that how to make progress towards the goal of nivrtti-marga. That is
stated, mahat-sevam dvaram ahur vimukteh [SB 5.5.2]. If you associate with
devotees, mahat, mahatma, great soul... Who is great soul? Great soul means who
has understood God. He is great soul. He is called mahatma. That is stated,
mahatmanas tu mam partha daivim-prakrtim asritah bhajanty ananya-manaso [Bg.
9.13]. Mahatma means he is not under the condition of this material nature. He
is under the protection of the spiritual nature, he is mahatma. You have to live
under somebody. That is our position. You cannot say that "I am not living under
somebody. I am independent." No. That is not possible. Nobody can say. Can
anybody say that "I am independent"? No. Because our constitutional position is
that, to serve. Either I serve my family or serve my community or serve my
nation or serve my government -- in this way go on increasing -- but your
position is to serve. You... Here you will find, therefore, that the so-called
master is also servant. Just like President Nixon. He was elected the master,
president, but actually he was the servant of the popular vote. As soon as he
became unpopular, he was immediately dismissed. So the president of a big state
is the position that he is a servant. How you are not a servant? That is our
nature. So people are engaged in service generally. "Generally" not. That is the
law. If one hasn't got to serve anybody, no family, no children, no wife, then
he keeps a dog, to serve him. Is it not a fact? I have seen in the Western
countries, old man who has no family, his whole day he is keeping a dog and
seeing the television. That's all. (laughter) Because nature is to serve. That
you cannot... Therefore pravrtti-marga means that we are trying to become false
master, sense gratification.
Actually, we are the servant of
the senses. We are not master. When you become master of the senses, then this
title is given, gosvami, svami. Svami means master. Master means master of your
senses. Now we are being dictated by the senses, 'You do this," we do that. So
our master is the senses, and the senses are six kinds of senses: Kama,
kamadina, lusty desires; lobha, greediness; and mohah, illusion; kama, krodha,
anger, mind... Mind is dictating something; I am serving: "Yes, sir, I will do
it." This is our position. Kama, krodha, lobha, mohah, matsarya, in this way. So
by good association, by saintly man's association... That is recommended:
mahat-sevam dvaram ahur vimukteh [SB 5.5.2]. Mahat-seva. This human life is
meant for rectification. We are serving somebody, and we are not happy. We have
got very good example in our country, in many other countries. Just like our
Mahatma Gandhi, he served his country very well, but the result was that his
countrymen killed him. This is the result of our service. Nobody will
appreciate. We are serving our family. The wife is not satisfied; (s)he divorces
the husband. The son is not satisfied; he goes out of home. So just analyze that
we are serving to our best capacity, but nobody is satisfied. This is our
position. Kamadinam katidha na katidha palita durnidesa. Actually we are serving
our senses. I love my wife because she satisfies my senses. I love my husband
because he satisfies my senses. Actually, we are servant of our senses. As soon
as the sense gratification is disturbed, then "No, no, I am not going to serve
you." Or "I am not satisfied with your service. You go away. I go away." This is
our position.
So senses are there. So one who
is associating with the devotees... Devotees mean who is engaged in the service
of the Lord. He is not engaged in the service of the senses. That is devotee.
Devotion... The definition of devotion is given in the sastra,
sarvopadhi-vinirmuktam
tat-paratvena
nirmalam
hrsikena hrsikesa-
sevanam bhaktir ucyate
[Cc. Madhya 19.170]
Sarva upadhi-vinirmuktam. Upadhi means designation. I am
spirit soul, but because I have accidentally..., or my result action, resultant
action of my past karma, I am thinking, "I am Indian," somebody is thinking "I
am American." So this is the designation of the soul. I am neither Indian, nor
somebody is American, somebody is Australian. We are living soul, aham
brahmasmi. That is my position. But being designated in a different way, I have
become a servant of that designation. So bhakti... Bhakti means nivrtti-marga,
to become free from all these designations. That is called bhakti. The
definition of mukti, or liberation, or becoming free from the designation, is
given in the Srimad-Bhagavatam, muktir hitvanyatha rupam sva-rupena
vyavasthitih: Mukti means when we give up the service in designation and we are
situated in our original constitutional position. That is called mukti,
liberation, or salvation, whatever you like. Muktir hitvanyatha rupam
sva-rupena. What is my own constitutional position? I am eternal servant of God,
Krsna. This is my position. So when we give up all these designation service and
engage myself in the real service of the real master, that is called mukti,
liberation.
So this Krsna consciousness
movement is trying to educate men that "After all, you are servant. You have to
serve somebody. You are now serving your senses. Now just divert your service to
Krsna, or God, and you will be happy. That's all." The service, constitutional
position, will not change. That is my position. In Bengali there is a proverb,
dheki svarge gelo dhana bhange.(?) The dheki, that's a wooden machine for
husking grain. So I do not know whether it is used in your country. It is a
big... It is peddled by the legs, and the grains are taken away the skin. So if
this dheki, this machine, is sent to heavenly planet, what he will do? The same
business: "Dag! Dag! Dag!" That's all. So either you go to the heavenly planet
or you remain here or you remain in animal kingdom, your... Even the trees, they
are standing -- they are giving service. They are giving you fruits, they are
giving you flowers, and if you want his service, by the wood, by the body, you
cut; it will not protest. "All right, you take my body." So that is the way to
understand that we must render service to somebody higher. So why not go to the
Supreme, the great -- "God is great" -- and render service? This is Krsna
consciousness. Then we'll be happy. You can go on giving service in this
material world under so many designation, but you will never be happy, and the
person to whom you are giving service, he will be not happy. This is material
world. Try to understand.
Therefore one devotee, he says,
kamadinam katidha kathidah na palita durnidesas tesam mayi na karuna jata na
trapa nopasantih, sampratam labdha-buddhis tvam ayatah niyunksvatma-dasye. This
is called good sense. The purport of this verse is, "My dear Lord, I have served
my senses in the form of lusty desires and anger and so many things, kama,
krodha, lobha, greediness, and..." My senses are, means, these things. "So I
have served life-long, but neither they are satisfied, neither I am satisfied."
Tesam. "And they are not merciful. I have served them up to the age of eighty
years, but still they want service from me. If I want to retire, they will not
agree." If somebody says to his wife that "I have served so much in the family.
Now let me go to the Krsna conscious temple. I serve there," the wife will
disagree, "No. What service you have done? You have got duty, duty, this duty,
that duty."
So it will never end, even if you
give lifelong service. Just like I have given the example: Gandhi gave lifelong
service according to his own. Hitler gave lifelong service. Napoleon gave
lifelong service. But their ultimate end was very, very regrettable. Nobody
realized his service. He was punished. This is material world. We have to
understand very clearly, and we have to take lesson from this verse that we may
go on serving our lusty desire, greediness, anger, and so on, so on, but we will
never come to the end and become happy. When one comes to the point that "I have
rendered service in so many ways. So neither I am happy nor the person to whom I
have served, they are happy. Then what is the remedy?" That is discussed in the
Vedanta-sutra philosophy. Athato brahma jijnasa: "Now inquire about your real
master, Brahman, or the Supreme, the great, the Absolute Truth." That is
required. So we should be prepared like that, that we have served our
propensities, different propensities, lusty desire, greediness, anger, kama,
krodha, lobha, mohah... Mohah means illusion. I am doing something wrong, and I
am thinking it is all right. This is called illusion, mohah. Matsarya. Matsarya
means envious, to become envious. Every one of us, either individually or
socially or community-wise or nationally, we are all envious. The Russians, they
are envious of the Americans, and the Americans, they are envious of the
Russians. Similarly, everyone. That is the nature. So we are serving all these
propensities. Now, this is called pravrtti-marga, progress towards sense
gratification in different ways. And if we stop that and make progress to our
real self-realization, real happiness, that is called
nivrtti-marga.
So this morning I was talking
with one gentleman. He is in charge of the social welfare. So when I proposed
that "Our nivrtti-marga..., we recommend these processes: no illicit sex, no
meat-eating, no intoxication, and no gambling, beginning," so he was not
satisfied. He said that "Why you stop illicit sex? We get pleasure." So this is
the understanding of the modern civilization. He is risking his life by all
these processes, but if we request that "Stop this process. Come to Krsna
consciousness," they will not agree. That is the difficulty. Therefore this line
of action, nivrtti-marga, it is little difficult. But it is very easy. If one
understands the philosophy, what is the meaning of pravrtti-marga and what is
the meaning of nivrtti-marga, and if he is sane man, then he will accept, "Yes."
Just like if you go to a physician and you are suffering from a disease,
being... Say, just like nowadays there is prominent alcoholic treatment. People
are too much addicted to alcohol, and there are so many departmental treatment,
even for the priest also. I have seen one ad in a paper that in America there is
a hospital where especially the priestly class drunkard, they are treated.
(laughter) And five thousand patients are there. (laughter) So if the physician
says, "No, no, you give up your drinking habit," then he will be angry. Then how
he will be treated? That is the only medicine, that "You give up." It is not
very difficult thing. Nobody learns drinking from the birth. Now, even one has
learned drinking, now, all our students, you see practically. They are young
men. They are not old men. Their senses are still strong. But they have given
up. They have given up. They have given up illicit sex. They have given up
intoxication. They do not take even tea, do not smoke cigarette. Neither they go
to cinema, what to speak of going to other places. It is possible. But if we
give up all these things, then our beginning to the nivrtti-marga, our progress
towards back to home, back to Godhead, that is beginning.
So if we accept the process, it is not difficult. So our
life should be trained up in this way, nivrtti-marga. Then we can make process
for going back to home, back to Godhead. First of all we should understand that
we are part and parcel of God. That is stated in the Bhagavad-gita, and actually
it is fact. What is God? God means what we are doing, He is also doing, because
we are part and parcel. Just like your son, your daughter. They are your part
and parcel of your body. So what is the difference? They are also acting, you
are also acting. Similarly, God, Krsna, is the supreme father. So so far the
activities are concerned, the same. But the difference is that God is great; we
are small. That is the difference. God can create the so many planets. Just like
the sun globe, it is... There are other globes also. They are bigger than sun.
Anyway, the sun is very big. So God has created this big globe, means fourteen
hundred thousand times bigger than this earth -- or even this earth -- floating
in the air. You can float a big 747 airplane also floating in the air, but you
cannot make a globe like sun and floating in the air. That is the difference
between you and God. The creative power is there. Because we are part and
parcel, the value is there. Just like gold mine and a small particle of gold. So
small particle has... It will be called gold, and it has got some value. But not
as good as the gold mine. This is the difference between God and ourself. We
should understand. So if we give up this service to the senses and we engage
ourself in the service of the great... Everyone wants to serve the great. That
is natural. If one is serving ordinary mercantile firm, he is thinking of
getting some service in the government office. That is very secure. So if we
seek our service to the supreme government, Krsna, or God, then we will be
happy. That is Krsna consciousness movement.
If you actually want to be happy... Now you can see.
These boys they are chanting, dancing. This is not artificial. Artificial
dancing can be performed one day, two days, then finished. But they are doing
twenty-four hours. How they are doing, unless they are feeling some happiness,
transcendental happiness? They are not fools. They are not uneducated. They are
educated. They are coming from a good family. But they have sacrificed
everything, and they are enjoying this Hare Krsna chanting and dancing. Unless
they feel... Even the girls, they are also dancing. So there is transcendental
feeling of blissful life. Why? When one engages himself in the service of the
Lord. This is the purport, very simple thing. And as soon as he will serve the
designation, false service, he will spoil his time and will be under the
condition of material nature. Material nature, we are all conditioned by
material nature. Therefore we are changing body from one body to another. Now,
by the nature's own process, evolution, we have come to this human form of body
and we have got advanced consciousness, we have got direction like
Bhagavad-gita, Srimad-Bhagavatam. Hari guru vaisnava bhagavata gita.
Bhagavata-gita. Just our Madhudvisa Swami sung, we have got Krsna, we have got
spiritual master, we have got the books, Bhagavata, we have got Gita. Now let us
take advantage of it. These transcendental literature, we have taken much pain
to translate them into English so that you can understand. We have got fifty
books. So take advantage. It is not meant for the cats and dogs. It is meant for
the human being, not a particular class or nation. No. It is meant for all human
being. So take advantage of this knowledge, understand the philosophy of life,
that "I am eternal." Na hanyate hanyamane sarire [Bg. 2.20]. "I do not die after
the annihilation of this body. I accept another body." We have got two bodies:
this gross body and one subtle body. Just like you have got your coat, and
within the coat there is shirt, similarly, within this gross body, there is
another subtle body. This gross body is made of the material elements, earth,
water, air, fire, ether, these five elements. Panca. Panca means five. Your body
and my body, it is simply combination of these five material elements. This is
the covering, coat. And within this, there is another body. What is that? Mind,
intelligence, and ego. So everyone knows that you have got mind, I have got
mind. Everyone knows that you have got intelligence, I have got intelligence.
And everyone is puffed up with some identification, "I am this, I am that."
These three conception, this is called subtle. Subtle body. So we simply see the
gross body, but we do not see the subtle body. When death take place -- that
means this gross body is finished -- then the subtle body is there. And the
subtle body carries the soul to another gross body. That we cannot see.
Therefore we do not understand how this spirit soul is migrating, transmigrating
from one body to another. We do not see. Therefore our seeing should be through
knowledge, pasyati jnana-caksusa, not this gross seeing. Gross seeing is
imperfect. It has no value. We know. We should inquire that "This gross body is
finished. Now what about the subtle body?"
So we have to understand from
authoritative literature. The subtle body is working, just like when you sleep
your gross body is not working, but the subtle body, the mind, intelligence and
ego is working; therefore you dream. Your subtle body is lying is some
apartment, and you have gone to the seaside by the mental body. So, so long this
gross body is able, you again come and enter into this gross body, but when it
is not workable, then you have to find out another gross body in the womb of a
certain type of mother. This is the law of transmigration of the soul. That
subtle body will be carried by the laws of nature. According to the work you
have done to your whims, then a certain type of body will be offered to you. You
will be forced to enter into the womb of a certain type of mother, and the
mother will give you the body. That we have got, everyone, experience. In the
mother's body, after pregnancy, the body grows. Everyone knows it. So body grows
why? Because the soul has entered, and according to his karma, either good
mother or bad mother... So you are growing the same body or better body or lower
body, and when it is mature, then you come out. You begin again your life. That
is called pravrtti-marga. In this way we have to accept birth, death, old age.
As soon as you get this material body, there is birth, and as soon as there is
birth, there is death. And as soon as the body is there, it is growing old. It
is suffering disease.
So if you want to avoid these
four things... That is specially pointed out by Krsna, janma-mrtyu-jara-vyadhi
[Bg. 13.9]. You are solving your problems, but what, how you have solved your
birth, death, old age, and disease? That is the question by Krsna. Have you
solved? Then what is the use of solving problems? The real problem is there. But
if you want to solve this real problem, then you should take up this
nivrtti-marga. Nivrtti-marga means stop this way of sense gratification and take
to Krsna consciousness. That is the way. If you continue your misbehavior, at
the same time you want to cure your disease, that is not possible. Just like
this alcoholic treatment. They go to the psychiatrist and so experienced...
After all, if you do not give up this bad habit, then where is the question of
treatment? Where is the question of treatment? That is called... That is
explained in the sastra, hasti-snana. The example is very right. Hasti-snana.
Hasti, hasti means elephant. Elephant, they go into the water, in the lake, in
the pond, and very nicely cleanse their body. Body very nicely cleansed, and
after taking bath, as soon as it comes to the bank on the ground, he takes some
dust and throw over the body. So atonement... Sometimes we make atonement. I
have committed some sin. I go to church or go to temple. I make some atonement.
Then after finishing that business, again I do that business. So this kind of
habit will not help you. You must try to stop the bad habit. That you can do
when you are in the association of devotees. Otherwise it is not
possible.
Sometimes there is some
disagreement, that "Why one should not live outside the temple?" But that is
little difficult, because in the temple you get good association. Everyone is
trying to become free from this bondage of life. So there is some inspiration.
But if you live outside the temple... We are making this temple commodious so
that people may come here and live and learn the art, but if you do not live,
there is risk. Because sangat sanjayate kamah. If you live in certain
association, drunkard association, then you will learn gradually how to drink.
And if you live with the association of the devotees, then you will forget
drinking. You will become devotee. So we are opening these centers, giving
chance everyone. There is no discrimination. It is not a religious system. It is
a cultural institution. Don't take as a religious. Religious is a kind of faith.
You may accept that faith or not. That is your discretion. But Krsna
consciousness is not a kind of faith. It is an cultural institution. If you,
actually, you are serious that "I must stop these inconveniences of birth,
death, and old age," then you must join this Krsna consciousness movement. That
is my request. That is called nivrtti-marga. And gradually, you will be elevated
to the topmost position, that you have no more attraction for these material
things. That is possible. It is not that impossible. Simply one has got to
follow the process.
The process is generally adau
sraddha. Adau sraddha, in the beginning... Just like you have come here with
some honor or with some respect. That is called sraddha. Sraddha means faith:
"All right, let us go there. What is this Krsna conscious temple?" This is the
beginning, that you come. This is called sraddha. Then if you like it, "Now,
here the people, they speak nicely from the books," then you come daily or
weekly and associate with the... Adau sraddha tato sadhu-sangah. Sadhu-sangah.
This is the process. First of all one must get a little faith and then associate
with the devotees. Adau sraddha tato sadhu-sangah atha bhajana-kriya. Then, by
associating with the devotees, we learn that "These devotees are worshiping the
Deity, they are chanting Hare Krsna mantra, and they are eating prasadam, and
they are very happy. So why not engage me also in this way?" So therefore
gradually they come and offer, "Now, sir, I shall join, and initiate me." In
this way we are doing. Adau sraddha tato sadhu-sangah tato bhajana-kriya adau
anartha-nivrttih syat. By execution of devotional service, whether you are
making progress or not, that will be tested when anartha-nivrttih syat, all the
nonsense things which you have learned artificially, that will be finished. That
is called anartha-nivrttih. Anarthopasamam saksad bhakti-yogam adho [SB
1.7.6].
We have created so many anarthas,
unwanted things, not required for me as spirit soul, but artificially, for this
designation body. So when one is engaged in actual devotional service, then the
result will be anartha-nivrttih. Same nivrtti. Nivrtti means finished. It is not
that all our students were free from this alcoholic habit or meat-eating or
illicit sex, no. They were habituated. But because they have taken to the
devotional service, this is all finished. Anartha-nivrttih syat. Then spiritual
life begins. Tato nistha: "Yes, it is very nice. I shall continue." This is
called nistha, firm faith. The beginning was faith, and after anartha-nivrtti,
firm faith, "Yes, I shall continue." Tato nistha tato rucih. How one can be
firmly fixed up unless he has got a taste for it? He relishes, "Yes, this
chanting and dancing is very nice." That is called relish. Tato nistha tato
rucih tathasaktih. Then he becomes attached. He cannot give it up. Asaktih.
Asaktih means attachment. Just like we have got attachment for so many things.
So these are the stages. Tathasaktih tato bhavah. Then ecstasy. And then you
come to the platform of loving God. Now we are loving cats and dogs. We shall
love God. This is the way.
Thank you very much.
Madhudvisa: Are there any
questions? Yes.
Devotee (1): At the point of
death, the gross body returns back to the earth. Is there ever a time when the
subtle body dies?
Madhudvisa: At the time of death
the gross body returns to the earth. Is...?
Prabhupada: The gross body is
finished. Gross body becomes ash, stool, or earth. Those who are burying the
gross body, it becomes after sometimes earth. And those who are giving this body
to be eaten by other animals, it becomes stool. And those who are burning this
body, the body becomes ash. So gross body there are three ultimate goal: either
to become ash, or stool, or earth.
Madhudvisa: His question was "Is
there a time when the subtle body ceases to exist?"
Prabhupada: Yes, that is
liberation. When... So long you are encircled by the subtle body, there is no
question of liberation because the subtle body will take you to another gross
body. When we are free from the subtle body, then we are liberated. We go back
to home, back to Godhead. Yes?
Devotee (2): What's the subtle
body like?
Prabhupada: I have already
explained. Mind, intelligence, and ego -- this is subtle body. Everyone has got
his mind, everyone knows. But we cannot see. The intelligence... Everyone has
got intelligence, but we cannot see. Similarly, subtle body is invisible. Ghost
means when the living entity remains in the subtle body, do not get another
gross body -- they are very sinful -- they create disturbance. But we cannot
see. That is ghost. Ghost means that those who are too much sinful, they do not
get this gross body. They are punished with the position, to remain in the
subtle body, at least for some time. That is ghostly life. Therefore you will
see, ghostly-haunted places, something is being done, but how it is being done,
you do not see because you cannot see the subtle body. But you will see
something is being carried in the air. It is not something being carried. It is
being carried by the subtle body. But I have no eyes to see the subtle body.
That is practical. I do not see your mind, but you have got your mind. You do
not see my mind. You can see my mind by the action. That's all. The subtle body
is there. Gross body, subtle body. Death means finishing of this gross body, and
liberation means no more association with the subtle body, only spiritual. That
is called liberation.
Madhudvisa: Srila Prabhupada? How
does one become free from that ghostly body?
Prabhupada: Ghostly body means he
has to suffer for some time. Just like you are put into prison. After your term
is finished, then you are liberated. Similarly, a most sinful man, he is given
this term, "You remain for some years in the subtle body." Everything is like
that. This is also. We have got this body, gross body, under certain condition.
When that condition is finished, then I give up this body, I create another
condition, and I enter another body. This is going on. Yes?
Woman: If we are all liberated in
the end, and if we all reach Godhead, why is it necessary...
[break]
Madhudvisa: ...reach Godhead in
the end, why do we have to speed up the process? Why not we just let things take
their natural course of events if everyone's going back to Godhead
ultimately?
Prabhupada: Hmm. That is a good
suggestion, but you rot for the time being. Suppose you are going somewhere,
walking, and somebody gives you opportunity, "Come in my car," why don't you
take advantage of it? You are... You will reach the destination by walking in
six thousand years, (laughter) but if you get the opportunity... In your country
there is good. There is staircase and there is elevator. So if you want to go,
that "I shall go by the staircase and reach the upstair at the end of the day
when office will be finished," (laughter) then you can do that. But if you are
intelligent, you shall take the advantage of the elevator. Within a minute you
go there. That is intelligence. "I am going. I shall reach at the end of the day
when every office will be closed. Then I will come down again." If you see that,
that you can do -- not very good intelligence. That is not intelligence. We have
to take the speediest process. That is intelligence. Yes?
Devotee (3): Srila Prabhupada, if
a devotee fills his life with devotional service right from the time he is born,
is that enough to attain the spiritual body? Will he necessarily
be...
Prabhupada: Yes, he is liking to
serve me, that is the action of the spiritual body.
Devotee (3): Even though he might
be...
Prabhupada: Therefore, if you
actually always remain in spiritual understanding, that means to understand
Krsna, or God. Then Krsna says, if you have understood what is God, that makes
you qualified to go back to home, back to Godhead. Janma karma ca me divyam yo
janati tattvatah [Bg. 4.9]. If you know what is God factually, then that is your
qualification to go back to home, back to Godhead. But if you do not know, then
your spiritual life has not begun. You must know what is God. That is
knowledge.
bahunam janmanam ante
jnanavan mam
prapadyate
vasudevah sarvam iti
sa mahatma sudurlabhah
[Bg.
7.19]
The spiritual life means to understand yourself and
understand God and understand your relationship with God and act accordingly.
That is spiritual life. It is not difficult. How to understand God? You can
understand just like you understand so many things from books. So there is book,
God is explaining Himself, "I am like this." So you understand Him. Then you
become qualified. Yes?
Devotee (4): Srila Prabhupada, in
Bhagavad-gita it says that "Out of millions of men, only one may come to know
Me, and of millions who know Me, only one can understand." What are
ways...?
Prabhupada: Hmm? What is
that?
Madhudvisa: He's speaking about
the verse, "Out of millions of men who try for the path, only one may know Me,
and out of those who know Me, only very few know Me in truth."
Prabhupada: That is stated in
Bhagavad-gita also.
manusyanam sahasresu
kascid yatati
siddhaye
yatatam api siddhanam
kascin vetti mam tattvatah
[Bg.
7.3]
Where is Bhagavad-gita? Find out this verse. Manusyanam
sahasresu: "Out of many millions of men." The human life is meant for
understanding God. Then... He can understand, but the attempt is not there. They
are after sense gratification. Nobody is interested to understand God. Everybody
is interested in cats' and dogs' business, sense gratification. Therefore out of
many millions of men, one can understand that "My life is meant for other
purpose." That is called siddhi, perfection, "How I shall make my life perfect?"
This desire arises in one man out of millions. And they are simply engaged, how
to satisfy senses perfectly. But that will never be done. A sane man thinks that
"I have done it so many lives. I have not been satisfied. I have not become
perfection. Then where is perfection?" That inquisitiveness makes him eligible.
Just like adau sraddha. I have already explained. So after becoming siddha,
perfect... Perfect means one must know that "I am not this body; I am soul,"
aham brahmasmi. That is perfection of knowledge. So Krsna says, yatatam api
siddhanam: [Bg. 7.3] "Those who have become perfect, out of many millions of
them, one can understand what I am." It is not so easy to understand God. But if
you take the process as is recommended in the sastras by saintly person, then it
is easy. Otherwise it is not easy. If you speculate to understand God, that is
not possible. Then you go on and many, many years speculating. You will never
understand God. Either you take the shelter of Lord Jesus Christ or Krsna, if
you follow his instruction -- this is the way of understanding -- then you will
understand. But if you don't care for his instruction, then you will never
understand. This is the process. Hmm.
Devotee (5): Srila Prabhupada,
you were saying that only if one can understand the nature of God, then he can
go back home.
Prabhupada: Yes.
Devotee (5): But we have the case
of the four Kumaras who were wandering in the Vaikuntha planets, and yet they
had not become fully God-realized at that point, and yet they were allowed to
enter...
Prabhupada: Those who are going
to Vaikuntha planets, they are not fully realized of God? What does he
say?
Madhudvisa: He was citing the
instance of the four Kumaras who were traveling through the gates of the
Vaikuntha world, but actually they were not completely
God-realized...
Prabhupada: Therefore they are on
the gates of Vaikuntha, not within. You cannot enter the kingdom of God without
full understanding. So you have to be trained up. This is the life. You become
trained up to understand God, and you will enter the kingdom of God.
Hmm?
Devotee (6): Srila Prabhupada,
how does one associate with the devotees?
Prabhupada: Hmm? What is
that?
Madhudvisa: How does one
associate with the devotees?
Prabhupada: Oh, you do not
understand? You can come and live with these devotees. Where is the difficulty?
You can live here, you can take prasadam, and without any charge. Still, you are
asking? This is the way. Adau sraddha tatah sadhu-sangah [Cc. Madhya 23.14-15].
You have to make your association with the devotees. Then you will learn.
Hmm.
Devotee (7): How much more
difficult is it for one born in a family of nondevotees to become a devotee than
a person who has been born in a family like Prabhupada's?
Prabhupada: Sadhu-sanga means you
have to give up the association of nondevotees. This question was asked to Sri
Caitanya was asked to Sri Caitanya Mahaprabhu by a devotee. He was householder.
So he inquired, "My dear Sir, what is the real standard of behavior of a
devotee?" He immediately answered that asat-sanga tyaga ei vaisnava-acara [Cc.
Madhya 22.87]. "Vaisnava devotee, his first behavior is he should give up
unwanted association." That is first. Now, the next question will be: "What is
that unwanted association?" He answered, asat eka stri-sangi krsnabhakta' ara:
"This unwanted association means people who are too much attached to sex life,
they are unwanted. And the another: nondevotee of God. They are unwanted." So
you be careful not to mix with these people and come to the devotional service,
then your life is perfect.
Devotee (8): Srila Prabhupada,
does a disciple first accept his spiritual master within the heart when he takes
initiation?
Madhudvisa: What is the question
again?
Devotee (8): When a disciple
takes initiation, does he first take initiation within the heart?
Prabhupada: Initiation is the
third stage. First stage is that... Just like you have come. This is called
sraddha, faith, little faith, not full faith. Then you have to increase this
faith by association of devotee. That is required. And when the faith is
increased, then the question of initiation. Initiation should not be immediately
offered. That will be misused. Therefore when we initiate, we inquire from the
head of the temple, "How long he is coming? What is his behavior?" If he
certifies that "Yes, he is doing nice," then we initiate. Our initiation is not
so cheap, "You come and be initiated." No, we do not do that. We must test you
first of all. Then we initiate.
Madhudvisa: His question was that
can you take initiation by accepting the spiritual master in your heart without
actually taking...
Prabhupada: These are bogus
proposition. It has no meaning. (laughter) It has no meaning. If you think
within yourself, "I am eating," will you be satisfied? You starve and simply
think, "I have eaten everything." (laughter) Is that very practical proposal?
You must eat. We don't say all these bogus proposition. All right. Thank you
very much. (end)
>>> Ref. VedaBase =>
Srimad-Bhagavatam 6.1.1 -- Melbourne, May 21, 1975
© 2001 The Bhaktivedanta Book Trust International.